Strange #5: A Medical Review
Strange #5
J.Michael Straczynski and Sammi Barnes, writers
Brandon Peterson, penciler
Med school is four years long, not eight. While there are some schools that offer a joint undergraduate degree and an M.D. in one sitting, they’re six years in length. Sure, an undergraduate degree and medical school added together equal eight years, but we don’t call that “medical school”, we call that “college AND med school.”
Of course, It could be that Strange just isn’t very bright and it took him twice as long to get through medical school.
As for the comic (and the series) itself:
The cardstock cover is nice. Not the art; the cover itself.
There, I said something nice about the book.
This series is a complete waste of time, money, imagination and paper. I cannot see how any aspect of the original Lee and Ditko Dr. Strange has been improved at all by these comics.
Story of redemption? Barely, it’s more the story of a predestined savior whose failures weren’t even his own fault.
Poetic spells and incantations? Nope, now we have large balloons of chicken scratch.
Clea: Mysterious stranger risking her own life by helping a man she barely knows against the evils of Dormammu? Nope. Now she’s a sly secret agent .
Inventive art showcasing imaginative magic spells? Nope, we’re treated to the lightsaber duel from Star Wars all over again.
The art? The art on Strange is like eating a meal entirely of sugar. Sure it tastes good at first, but there’s nothing remotely filling (or even healthy) about it in the long run.
So there you have it: Strange will rot your teeth.
April 21st, 2005 at 11:27 am
I’m glad I stopped with the first issue.
April 21st, 2005 at 1:03 pm
I’d stick with the ‘He’s an idiot’ reason, but, is it possible he went for four years to become a doctor in, say, proctology and then said ‘Err, on second thought, OB/GYN is where its at’ and went back?
Pardon my lack of knowledge on how all them there doctors became such :)
April 21st, 2005 at 1:08 pm
Official Comment
Specialties are determined by residency, which takes place after medical school not during it. Strange could be talking about residency I guess, but there are no 4-year surgical residencies. I think it’s mostly a bad timeline (which I’ve been complaining about since the first issue).
April 23rd, 2005 at 7:39 pm
Nitpick: about “While there are some schools that offer a joint undergraduate degree and an M.D. in one sitting, they’re six years in length,” doesn’t this vary from school to school? When I was a high schooler Rensselaer offered it in 6 years, BU in 7, and Brown in 8…
Leave a Reply
Contact Me
Subscribe:
The Best Of...
Special Topics
Archives
Categories
Arbitrarily Interesting Medical Condition
Twitter
Comic Blogs
Medical Blogs
Currently Reading
The Net: