Polite Dissent

Eleventh Hour is yet another science/action/mystery show. This one is about the overly brilliant Dr. Jason Hood, biophysicist and “Special Science Advisor” to the FBI, along with Rachel, the attractive yet hard-as-nails FBI agent who accompanies him. Cloning is the subject of the first episode, as Jacob and Rachel hunt the mysterious Gepetto, a scientist who is trying to clone humans using innocent women as surrogate mothers.

The science is definitely better than Fringe, though the characters aren’t as interesting. The plot was compelling, despite a few plot holes (such as…how stupid is the surrogate mother not to realize something isn’t kosher? Or does she really think it is normal to have an obstetrical examination in an abandoned warehouse?)

1. Cloning
As Science not Fiction points out in their review, the science is reasonable, and the explanation of cloning given is fairly straight-forward and easy to understand. It’s easily the best depiction of cloning in a television show that I can recall.
For the record, the worst I can remember are the clone storylines in The Flash (Episode 18: Twin Streaks) and the live action The Amazing Spider-Man from the ’70s (Episode 5: Night of the Clones).
Why are the police running a DNA lab in a tent in the forest? It’s a delicate procedure and that’s just asking for contamination. (”The DNA appears to be half human and half oak. So let’s get the team out there looking for an Ent!”)

2. Placenta Previa
When the placenta covers the internal os (the opening between the uterus and birth canal), it is known as placenta previa. The condition is graded by how much of the os is covered. In Grade III placenta previa (mentioned on the show) — which is also known as partial placenta previa — the os is partially covered by the placenta. As you can imagine, this makes it a challenge to give birth vaginally. C-sections are the recommended delivery method in this situation*.

The classic symptom of placenta previa is painless vaginal bleeding during pregnancy, which is not what was shown on the show. Painful vaginal bleeding is more indicative of a placental abruption (when the placenta pulls away from the wall of the uterus), a much more dangerous condition**.

3. CPR
While I applaud the show for resisting the temptation to defibrillate a flatline, that has to be one of the worst examples of Hollywood CPR ever.

Television and movie CPR is almost always done incorrectly, with bent elbows instead of straight arms — but there’s a good reason for this because you don’t want to injure the actor portraying the victim. This scene was worse than that, with nearly everything done wrong, such as — in addition to the bent elbows — improperly placed hands, a patient who was up too high for good CPR, and too rapid a pace. In the end, to show he was really trying hard, Dr. Hood increased the speed of his compressions even more — but this is the worst thing he could have done. You have to give the heart time to fill with blood between compressions; faster compression means the heart doesn’t have time to fill, and the resulting CPR is worse, not better***.

Notes:
*Bear in mind that a placenta previa is fairly common in early pregnancy, and will usually shift away from the os as the uterus grows during pregnancy. So, delivery-wise, placenta previa is only a concern when it occurs late in pregnancy.

**Admittedly, placenta previa can sometimes stimulate premature contractions, which can be quite painful, but that doesn’t seem to be what was shown here.

***Though they saved the patient in this situation, it would not have worked like this in real life. She had flatlined because she had hemorrhaged and lost a tremendous amount of blood. Until that blood loss is corrected, it’s going to be impossible to get her heart restarted (especially with bad CPR).
Speaking of blood, why would there still be blood in a closed-down clinic?